Puzzle #419: X and O
Posted January 25, 2010 • #xando
For your puzzling amusement today, an X and O puzzle. Deduce the strings that the letters represent using the concatenated strings given.
Comments
David Millar • 02/07/10 12:19 pm
Sorry about that Josh. The second clue should have been FDFB, not ADFB. That should clear up the puzzle and make it solvable. I will double check and repost the PDF shortly.
mathgrant • 02/07/10 12:56 pm
Now in the posted puzzle (the one Josh helped you fix), there's no clue to what E is. It could be XXXXOOOXOXO, for all we know.
Remove "E" from the list of strings we have to solve for, and it'll work. :)
David Millar • 02/07/10 1:13 pm
Actually, the puzzle does have an E - it's in the sequence directly above that set of 2 clues. The letters references in AEBA & EDE are the same strings as the letters in BFCA & FDFB. Although the bottom half can be solved on its own, the top is necessary for the answer to E.
Any suggestions on a better way to show that those are both part of the same puzzle would be much appreciated!
mathgrant • 02/07/10 1:41 pm
Oh. . . you're right. Wow, I feel. . . blind. :)
David Millar • 02/07/10 2:33 pm
That's alright. Like I said: I know it's not well-designed. I'm going to try redesigning it this evening I think.
Leave Your Comment
Don't Miss New Puzzles!
Info for Teachers
Want to use my puzzles in your class? Feel free to do so! I only ask a few things in return:
- If you want me to hold back the solution for any puzzle that you plan to use, please let me know ahead of time. Otherwise I may honor requests for solutions and accidentally help some students cheat.
- If you would like a copy of a puzzle without my blog header and contact info, please contact me and I'll do my best to provide a PDF that meets your needs.
- If you would like more puzzles of a particular type, easier or harder puzzles of a type, or some other custom request for puzzles, worksheets, or other materials, please contact me. I'm happy to help for free as time permits.
Joshua Zucker • 02/04/10 3:28 pm
I'm pretty sure there's an error in this puzzle. The only "solution" I can find to the BFCA & ADFB puzzle in the lower right is for B = A = OX and F=D=C=O, but the letters are supposed to stand for distinct strings. The fact that there's a start and end which are both A implies that A = OX, and same for B ... but maybe I'm missing something.